Fox Sports Radio Jacksonville

The Florida Gators suffered a heart-breaking overtime loss on the road in Knoxville against the Volunteers.

Saturday night was another familiar chapter in Billy Napier's tenure in Gainesville. The Gators dominated the first half and controlled the momentum for most of the game.

Yet, as we've seen repeatedly, Napier's squad failed to execute in critical situations, resulting from questionable play-calling decisions and a fundamental lack of discipline.

It was a game where Florida had a golden opportunity to turn its season around with a win over a top-ten-ranked SEC opponent, a chance they fought for but ultimately fell short, leaving them at 3-3 (1-2).

The loss makes the Gators 1-12 against AP Top 25 teams in Billy Napier's tenure, and the back half of the schedule doesn't get easier.

Not only did Florida suffer a tough loss, but the Gators' two best offensive players also exited the contest with injuries.

Quarterback Graham Mertz and runningback Montrell Johnson Jr. left the contest with leg injuries in the second half.

Mertz ended the night 11/15 for 125 yards and a touchdown; Johnson Jr. finished the evening with 12 carries for 85 yards at 6.1 yards per carry.

Johnson was a massive part of the Florida offensive success. Before his injury, he moved the ball, recording three runs of 10+ yards and two runs of 20+.

DJ Lagway took over the rest of the second half, finishing the night 9/17 for 98 yards with a touchdown and an interception.

The 27-yard touchdown pass to Chimere Dike in the fourth quarter tied the game up after the Gators blew a 10-0 first-half lead.

The interception was brutal; Lagway failed to recognize the flat defender in cover two while trying to hit an out route in the hole on the sideline. The defense ended up holding the Volunteers to a field goal off the turnover.

The situational incompetence of the Gator's offense lost them this football game. The unit reached the Tennessee red zone four times in the first half and came away with three total points heading into halftime.

The red zone trips included a 42-yard field goal, a turnover on downs at the 18-yard line, a fumble at the 1-yard line, and an illegal substitution that took away a field goal.

Florida could tack on the extra field goal at the end of the 2nd quarter. Graham Mertz took a third sack down with no time-outs, leading the field goal unit to suffer an illegal substitution in an attempt to drill a field goal as the final seconds ticked off.

It was inexcusable for Mertz, a sixth-year senior, to lack situational awareness at the end of the half, costing his team points.

“We left a ton of points out there,” Napier said after the game.

The Florida defense has improved mightily following the bye. The unit suffocated the Volunteer offense in the first half and, indeed, dominated the line of scrimmage.

The defense finished the night with eight tackles for loss and three sacks, with two forced turnovers.

The Gators held the high-powered Tennessee rushing attack to just 3.3 yards per carry and two explosive runs from Dylan Sampson.

The secondary did a serviceable job limiting explosives from through the air from Nico Iamaleava, allowing just nine passes of 10+ yards and three passes of 20+.

On paper, Florida should have won this game. Billy Napier's future had the potential to be altered with a statement win in Neyland, yet to no surprise, the Gators fell short in crunch time.

The Florida Gators are back home in the Swamp next week for a primetime SEC matchup with Kentucky at 7:45 PM ET.

The Herd with Colin Cowherd